The Wrangler

Parody or Prose?

A 77-page parody can have more power than expected.

By Gaurang Dhingra, Staff Writer, Staff Photographer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






In the midst of the uproar caused by the elimination of Vine’s social media platform, and its devolution into the mere “Vine Camera,” Emily Beck and Adam Gasiewski had a lightbulb moment.

The pair of Temple University students had produced an ode to Vine by comprising a thin volume of parody titled Milk and Vine, which was founded on the principle of Milk and Honey, a sincere poetry book written by Rupi Kaur.

Kaur’s book was the work which pulled her into the literary spotlight, as her work was speckled with romantic and wistful undertones. Her poems were written in short, even sequences of words and varied in their overall length. Additionally, the poems in Milk and Honey were accompanied by sketches which dangled below the words and often represented a particular subject which was expressed in the stanzas above. Kaur’s success was attributed to a particular subculture of the population which had an eye for poetry books–a subculture that attempted to radiate the facade of deep philosophical thinking and a sophisticated association with the emotions of angst. This particular subculture has often been found intolerable by many who roam the internet, as they put up a front of sophistication which is often absent, and many of its members have claimed to dabble in fine arts, but express themselves in a style which is almost uniform to Kaur’s, even before Milk and Honey was published.

her work was speckled with romantic and wistful undertones”

For that reason, it’s almost effortless to imagine the number of people Milk and Vine, a parody of Kaur’s book, upset upon its initial publication in late October of last year. Many claimed the parody was insulting and degrading to Kaur’s honest work, while others admired it for its humor.

Beck and Gasiewski’s book, Milk and Vine contained short, choppy lines of words arranged in the Times New Roman font which wrote phrases uttered from several iconic vines. In order to follow suit, the students sketched doodles pertaining to their respective vines, just as Kaur did with her piece.

Despite severe backlash from fans of Milk and Honey and content creators whose vines were featured, the couple settled that they had discussed copyright regarding their book and the vines they showcased, and eventually even credited the creators of those vines. Ultimately, the book prospered and climbed Amazon’s #1 Bestseller List.

Due to the tremendous success of their first parody, the two released a continuation, adequately titled Milk and Vine II, which contained twice as much content as its predecessor this January. On this second time around, the parody didn’t receive nearly as much opposition as the original did, which can be attributed to the inclusion of a foreword and the crediting of content from the get-go.

Beck and Gasiewski have enraged many, but it seems they’ve brought more laughs than grimaces in the grand scheme of things. The pair has successfully contributed to maintaining the nostalgia of Vine by immortalizing several popular vines.

Only one question remains: is there a Milk and Vine III on the way?

That, only time will tell.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    Accutane: When All Else Fails

  • FEATURES

    Vogue in September

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    September: An Important Month in Fashion

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    The Life of a Struggling Artist

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    Finding Balance

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    Are You Smarter than a Four Year Old?

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    Dead Men Walking

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    The Royal Wedding

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    The ‘Fine Print’

  • Parody or Prose?

    FEATURES

    National Walk Out in Protest Against Gun Violence

The student news site of George Ranch High School
Parody or Prose?